A Darker World Is Not Far From Us

Chaos has always been portrayed as more than just another enemy. Whilst the Imperium stood at the heart of the 40k story with the xenos races arrayed around it like wolves waiting to pull the big beast down, Chaos was the Imperium’s equal – its dark reflection. One is led to believe that the Imperium could hold back any one of the xenos threats with ease, if only they were attacking it one at a time like bad guys in a martial arts film. The eldar are too few now to present a real danger, the tau too small and isolated. The orks, as is always noted, could destroy us all – if only they stopped fighting each other for long enough to knock over humanity’s sandcastles. Of course we’re told that the tyranids and/or necrons will soon kill everyone, but this is generally presented as something of a “by-the-way” which to me means it has often seemed either a distant threat, or so overwhelming as to make all other faction’s involvement seem pointless.

Plague Marines 2

Not chaos though. Chaos is in all of us. Every man who marches in the armies of the Imperium could someday turn his coat and fight beneath the eight-pointed star instead. If the Imperium fielded an army of just one man then that man might turn his back on the Emperor and fight instead for the Ruinous Powers. If they sent an army a billion strong to defeat him then they might win… or they might find a billion new enemies marching back towards them. The tau can be eradicated, the eldar driven to extinction, the Imperium brought to ruin and the numberless swarms of the tyranids exhausted, but so long as a single human remains alive in the galaxy Chaos will never die.

Like an infection it leaps from one carrier to the next. No-one is entirely immune, regardless of what the Grey Knights will tell you, and once a person is corrupted they will inevitably seek to corrupt others. Should the right person fall billions more can fall with them. Corrupt a planetary governor and a whole world can tumble. When Horus fell half the Imperium followed.

Fight it head on and you only feed it. Try to ignore it, deny its reality, smash the churches and burn the holy books, and Chaos sneaks back in via the back door.

Horrors

We know of course that there are various factions within all of the races, clans of orks, necron dynasties, tyranid hive fleets and so on. You’re encouraged to paint them different colours, and – especially since the arrival of Warhammer 40k’s 8th edition – there are even rules so that they perform differently in the game. The eldar have a bit more depth; there are the craftworlders, the dark kin of Commortagh, the dancing harlequins of the Black Library, the newly formed Ynnari and, for enthusiast convertors, even exodites and corsairs. Really though it’s the Imperium to whom the greatest attention has been devoted. We have six brands of space marine alone, various imperial guard regiments, the wonderfully weird tech-cult of the Adeptus Mechanicis, the towering knights, the golden armoured Custodes, the shadowy Inquisitors, the one man armies of the Assassinorum and those perpetually overlooked nuns with guns – the Sisters of Battle. The thing is, Chaos is always described as having all that and more. Four distinct gods place their influence upon chaos space marine legions, traitor primarchs, rebel guard regiments, beastmen herds, daemonic choirs, fallen knight households and the daemon-smiths of the Dark Mechanicus. It’s as if there was another Imperium, a twisted reflection of the first, a Dark Imperium if you will.

The battle between the Imperium and Chaos then is not the story of the old empire falling to the barbarians at the gates but the story of two equals fighting for dominance. The Empire of the Eye has stood almost as long as the Imperium and its history is just as rich and complex as that of its real space reflection.

Roboute Guilliman

When Roboute Guilliman arrived in the 40k setting earlier this year I was furious. I even wrote a long and extremely angry blog post, which thankfully I never posted, decrying the state of the world and GW’s decision to put profit over quality. To me the daemon primarchs belonged in the setting and their return was welcome but their flesh and blood brothers should have stayed dead. I got over it though. Guilliman may walk and talk but the galaxy is a big place and his presence hasn’t impinged on my enjoyment of the game one way or another. I even read Guy Haley’s Dark Imperium (and, beneath my dwarf-like contempt for this newfangled tinkering with the established lore, secretly rather enjoyed it).

The age of the Emperor ended when he was placed upon the golden throne. This is the story of twin empires locked in a struggle to the death and of brothers fighting over their father’s kingdom.

Plague Bearers 2

Warhammer as was told the story of many races, empires and nations. Age of Sigmar is a veritable soup of them. Nor do all of those stories focus around human protagonists. Central themes in the World That Was included the age long struggle between the self-righteous Elves of Ulthuan and their infinitely superior kin in Naggaroth, whilst dwarves, skaven and goblins battled in the sunless depths without anyone in the Empire or Bretonnia even knowing about it.

Without Chaos however 40k runs the risk of being a one horse town, with the Imperium at the heart of every story. Sure there are epic confrontations going on in the margins, the Eldar battling the Tyranids at Valedor, the Orks also fighting the Tyranids in Octarius, but in the main it’s all been about the Imperium. What’s more, for all the Chaos has traditionally been presented as the biggest baddy of them all, in recent years it’s star had started to wane. Bigger threats were descending on the galaxy, threats which would see all human life obliterated regardless of whether they worshipped a corpse god or grew tentacles from their ears. Either the Necrons were going to wake up and obliterate all organic life with the flick of a switch or the Tyranids were going to eat everyone. Against this Chaos was starting to feel a little weak. To criticise poor old Abaddon because you’ve never read the background and his arms keep falling off has long been akin to waving a flag and publicly declaring you’re an ass but even so one started to wonder if his long war wasn’t taking a little bit too long. Surely if he didn’t crack on his hordes would eventually come pouring from the Eye of Terror only to find a galaxy stripped of life and nothing left to fight but a lone genestealer fighting a broken necron in the ruins of the Imperial Palace. It’s one thing to unite the warring Chaos legions beneath one banner, quite another to take so long doing it that you end up missing the apocalypse you were planning to unleash. Yet whilst Abaddon was running the risk of being the big baddie who get’s beaten at the end of every episode some filthy xenos were about to blow up the whole galaxy – and that would never do.

Bloodthirster

Now this isn’t intended to do down the xenos (some of my best friends are xenos) who enrich the setting so deeply or to claim special treatment for my army just because I’m super special myself. Indeed I’d like to see the various alien races expanded upon further and with luck GW are cracking on behind the scenes with exactly that. However when the threat they pose reaches apocalyptic levels it risks becoming too abstract, too overwhelming, to engage with alone. When one looks at the innumerable hordes of the Tyranids pouring in from the depths of space one tends to think that the Imperium might as well just go home and put their feet up, they’re all going to be eaten whatever they do so there’s not much point struggling especially not when they already have a galaxy-sized guass flayer to their collective heads. Chaos though is an enemy you can fight – not just with your bolters in the burning streets, not just on the tabletop, but in your own heart and soul. No-one looks at a Tyranid and thinks “I really understand where these guys are coming from! If I was living in the 41st Millennium I’d want to strip planets of their biomass too!” I can’t put myself in the shoes of a soulless Necron automaton, and even the Eldar and Orks are relatively inscrutable and inhuman to our gaze. Chaos though speaks to us, to our ambition, to our righteous anger, to our will to freedom and self-determination, to our hunger to live, to our moral drives and the very emotions that make us human.

The Imperium needs an enemy we can empathise with, an enemy that speaks to us in our own voice so that we can cringe with horrified fascination as they tear each other apart. Ultimately if GW are serious about the 40k setting evolving then the Imperium needs an equal. It needs Chaos.

All artwork used belongs to Games Workshop and is used without permission as a result of sheer badness on my part.

Advertisements

15 responses to “A Darker World Is Not Far From Us

  • davekay

    The Imperium needs chaos – I could not agree more with this sentiment. Chaos is the dark twisted reflection of the Imperium’s ideals, of what it claims to fight for and to be.

    Quite possibly the galaxy would be better off without either, which is more likely to be the xenos view ๐Ÿ˜‰

    • Wudugast

      Aye, I think if I lived in the 41st Millennium (and I knew it as well as I do now, rather than slaving in ignorance in some hive somewhere) I’d agree with the xenos. They may be one of my least favourite 40k factions (and not half as nice as they like to pretend) but I think I’d probably join the Tau.

  • Alex

    Good write-up mate. I hope & suspect that the recent ‘moving along’ of the story will continue to develop the dark forces into the adversary they should be… I wonder of the Prince of Pleasure will start to feature more???

    • Wudugast

      Here’s hoping! I’m confident we’ll see a similar pattern of releases play out for Slaanesh and Khorne as we did for Tzeentch and seem to be seeing for Nurgle. Then again I was confident we’d have seen a full Sisters of Battle release by now so what do I know? ๐Ÿ˜‰

  • imperialrebelork

    You
    Do
    Good
    Word
    Stuff

    Haha.
    I really enjoy your writings, scriptures, scribbles and ramblings.

    The imperium needs chaos like Scooby do needs Scooby snacks. Like Bonnie needs Clyde. Like the Heptfield needs Ulrick. Like… well you get the point.

    • Wudugast

      Precisely! I remember reading an interview with one of the GW designers and he was asked which model inspired him to start an Imperial Guard army. He said it was the tyranid carnifex because “if there are monsters like that in the galaxy then we need heroes to fight them”.

  • the28scribe

    The Imperium needs chaos like Sherlock needa Mycroft

  • FirBholg

    Love your take on this, both in terms of the Empire of the Eye (itโ€™s not like the Imperium hasnโ€™t had more than itโ€™s fair share of internecine conflicts), and the idea of brothers warring over their fatherโ€™s fallen empire (brings a bit more of a mythic quality to the reintridyction of loyalist Primarchs).

    You (and a couple of other bloggers) may have finally convinced me to pick up the Dark Imperium novel and check it out properly!

    • Wudugast

      Cheers ๐Ÿ™‚ I went into Dark Imperium determined to hate it. I read it only because I was curious about where they were taking the background and because I’d heard enough favourable reviews to sway me to give it a shot. Tie in novels for boxsets though – always a bit hit and miss! I was worried that with Gullieman back the setting would become a bit more black and white, the Imperium would turn into good guys led by their square-jawed new hero, vs the gribbly evil of chaos. Luckily the Imperium is still as ghastly and oppressive as ever, just with the addition of a primarch who’s baffled and frustrated by the way things have turned out after ten millennia. If you’ve read any of the Horus Heresy stuff it ties in nicely – especially if you’ve read anything with Guilleman in it. Indeed I’d say it’s a natural sequel to the Hersey.

      As for Imperium vs Imperium conflict I can see that getting worse since the opening of the Great Rift. I’ve always thought that the whole “training exercise” justification for Imperium vs Imperium battles was a bit lazy but there really is no need for it any more. Oh and I don’t believe for a moment that the Primaris marines are immune to the temptations of Chaos ๐Ÿ˜‰

      • LeVermenarque

        I feared the same black and white turn when Dark Imperium came out. I did not (my sin) read the books as you did and now I think I may.
        I think the reboot of Guilliman may offer some players to play good guys against bad guys since he can be “the absolute good guy”, something 40k was lacking.
        Now I with perspective I guess this is only one way to see it, as Dark Imperium has potential for even more internal struggle and narrative complexity, two things I welcome!

  • LeVermenarque

    Very nice post, very interesting and well written. Thank you.

    Being a former Eldar and now an Ork I would contest your point about Xenos oit of sheer dishonesty but I won’t since in the end I think you may well be right ๐Ÿ˜‰

    • Wudugast

      Cheers ๐Ÿ™‚ truth be told it was the orks that first got me into 40k and they’re still one of my favourite armies (although about five years before that I almost bought a friend’s necrons – I still slightly regret that I didn’t). Just recently another mate gave me his old eldar collection as part of a clear out so expect some pointy-ears to show up here soon. For all I’ve said here about the alien races they add so much flavour and depth to the setting, it would be very weak and sterile without them. Perhaps I should write a follow up blog – a love letter to the xenos?

Speak, damn you!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: