Rising From The Ruins: The Rebirth of Warhammer

So, almost a year on after Games Workshop spectacularly blew it up the Old World of Warhammer is back. The tabletop version may be officially dead but the world itself has been pulled from the grave by the digital necromancy of the Total War series.empire_vs_chaos_by_janiceduke-da3u5xl

Warhammer: Total War is a game I’ve been excited about for a little over a decade. As a student I was a big fan of the Total War series and recall expounding the idea of a fantasy version based on the Warhammer world to my (undoubtedly disinterested) friends and housemates. A digital format would allow me to indulge in the mass battles and complex campaigns to which I’ve aspired without the abstraction of the to-hit tables and dense rulebooks that come with tabletop games. It allows the introduction of characters like Kholek Suneater, without the need for it to be sculpted from a metric ton of resin. It also frees me from the need to paint hundreds of models, allowing me to focus on the creative conversions and detailed painting that I enjoy most.

Please note that this is not me trying to claim credit for the idea, unless of course you are an employee of Sega and want to send me a big, fat cheque. Furthermore, having played little in the way of computer games in recent years I’m probably not the best person to attempt to review one now, so instead I’ll philosophise in my usual rambling fashion about Warhammer instead.

chaos_lord_on_manticore_by_janiceduke-da3q6c3

As it stands the game includes five races; the Empire, Vampire Counts, Dwarves, Greenskins and Chaos (available as a downloadable add-on), plus a sixth race to be added for free later – probably Bretonia. The developers have also stated that, by the end of the trilogy, the game will feature all the major races. Exactly what this means however remains unclear. Is it safe to assume that if a faction had models in the tabletop game it will feature in the digital incarnation? It seems sensible to conclude that High Elves are a major race and Keislev is not but what about Beastmen, or followers of individual Chaos gods? I’d be being facetious if I suggested that Chaos Dwarves might make it in but whilst the Bretonian line has been cleared from Games Workshop’s stock over in the digital world some pretty broad hints have been dropped that the Knights of the Lady will soon be a playable race. Does that mean we can look forward to Tomb Kings in the future as well?

It’s all very exciting but here’s the interesting thing – Warhammer is dead. The word is repeated everywhere, on every forum online, in every gaming establishment and convention where the dice-loving public gather to bitch and moan. Games Workshop brought us a series of (impressively well produced) books that together make up the End Times, during which they effectively took off and nuked the entire world they’d spent over three decades creating from orbit. Rumour has it that the game wasn’t making any money, that it was creatively dead and that it just didn’t contain enough Space Marines to be viable. In many ways I was part of the problem, always dreaming about starting a Warhammer army yet never really getting round to it – then complaining when they took away something I wasn’t using anyway.

For those of you thinking ‘what about Warhammer Online? Surely we’ve been here before’ let me say three things. Firstly Warhammer Online was an MMO and thus appealed to its players in a very different way to a strategy game like Warhammer: Total War, Warhammer or Age of Sigmar. Secondly, it was released long before the End Times and so its significance as a window on the Old World was considerably less. Thirdly I never played it and don’t want to make too much of a fool of myself making assertions about it that I can’t substantiate.

karl_franz_riding_deathclaw_by_janiceduke-da3u59c

Let me define my position here. I’m generally opposed to tabletop games advancing the storyline. This is a setting in which people can and should create their own stories, not a series of novels or a computer game in which a characters advance along a journey (literal or metaphorical) and the world changes around them. The well-argued and highly recomended piece written at the launch of Age of Sigmar over at Ex Profundis argues that Tolkien would have saved the world, with Sigmar recovering at home surrounded by wellwishers, whilst Moorcock would have blown the whole thing up. I would have told both of them to back the hell off and stick to stories, not settings, where they belong. I love seeing the world change through a series of novels, love reading the history that leads up to the ‘present day’ in a war-gaming setting, but find progression beyond that to be generally a pointless, self-indulgent exercise. Bored of seeing the Emperor sitting on the Golden Throne for the last thirty years? Still waiting for Abaddon to make it out of the Cadian Gate or the Orks to win at Armageddon? Then pick up a book or watch a film. Asking for a setting like the Old World or the Imperium to change radically is like saying ‘The Mona Lisa is alright but I’ve been looking at it for years now and I don’t think it’s changed a bit!’

Having said all that the Old World was nothing like the Mona Lisa, but rather a roughly cut-and-pasted version, the off-cuts of better artists stuck together with poster-paint and PVA. Much of it was lifted directly from real world history with other influences crudely stitched on, from pulp horror Egyptians to knock-off hobbits. Depending on who was writing it at the time it was either gritty and driven by the actions of flawed mortals or mythic and driven by the actions of flawed gods. It was also generally extremely convoluted and relied heavily on every outcome being reached only through a series of highly improbable steps. You can’t blame them for wanting to rebuild with something new rather than just papering over the cracks.  It may have done the business back in the 80’s but it was hardly a world befitting of a company of Games Workshop’s stature. When they put a match to it I wasn’t sorry to see it going. I certainly did not want it to go all ‘there-and-back-again’ with Chaos packed off back to the northern wastes, the status-quo re-established and the peoples of good and order celebrating whilst their destructive neighbours plotted in their dens and swore their revenge.

The End Times were a good thing for Warhammer. It was the pruning it desperately needed, the infusion of new ideas and creativity that encouraged fresh growth coming alongside the forest fire that burned away the old and the stagnant. I enjoyed every moment, right up to the end where it all actually ended.

In Age of Sigmar the cracks are still there and bigger than ever with the tortuous narratives of old replaced by a lot of handwaving. It’s not even the case that everything in these realms is actually that original. Instead of borrowing from the real world it borrows from Warhammer.

Empire Captain 1

In Sigmar’s name!

The article at Ex Profudis asks “What good is an apocalypse without a post- apocalypse? …what is the point of an apocalypse if there is nothing left afterwards? This was the main question I had upon reading about Age of Sigmar. Why destroy everything? Surely there should be something left, a few hundred years in the future – to provide familiar elements and give a sense of narrative continuity: the ruins of Altdorf strangled by poisonous forest; an Elven child’s doll from Ulthuan washing up on daemon-scarred shores”.

During the End Times this was pretty much what I was expecting. The Old World would be changed, not so much that it was rendered unrecognisable, but enough to refresh it. I was fairly certain that the final battle would end in a draw, the portal collapsing in a cataclysmic explosion as the Chaos Gods withdrew in order to continue toying with the world. In the aftermath Chaos warbands would continue to rampage around the countryside, many Empire cities would burn – or turn into something similar to Mordheim, and the Elves would seek to re-establish themselves with many unable to accept their new king. Finecast characters would have gone out in blaze of glory and the ruined Bretonia would be ready for a reboot more complex than just ripping off the conservative romantic clichés of medieval feudalism. The world would be smaller with lots of the previously underdeveloped regions ripe for exploration. The Lizardmen – which people often complained were geographically too remote to make sense as protagonists in the majority of Warhammer battles – could bring their floating pyramids to drift sedately through the sky over the Empire. With Chaos still merrily setting fire to the countryside and much of their previous infrastructure lost, the forces of civilisation would be in need of any help they could get and, with a crack of thunder, Sigmar’s golden supermen could have descended from on-high to provide it.

Alternatively Nagash could have created a vast host of morghasts and used them to push Chaos back through the polar gate, using it to access the realms beyond and continue to expand his empire out into the stars. Then again perhaps that’s just because I think an undead emperor commanding legions of super-warriors to fight the servants of Chaos in space is quite a nifty idea for a setting…

The world would be ripe for new ideas but not so much as to alienate and divide the player base to the extent that the actual release of Age of Sigmar did. A game like AoS could still have been released, with Warhammer lingering in the background to be marketed to veteran players. At the time of the Old World’s destruction – still less than a year ago – the range of games produced by Games Workshop was very much in decline. Only 40k and Warhammer remained, with the Hobbit resting its head uncomfortably on the executioners block (the sort of image that would be produced if George R.R. Martin was allowed to re-write Lord of the Rings). In that culture it seemed unlikely that Warhammer could survive alongside Age of Sigmar. A mere few months later however Specialist Games was relaunched (although the name remains one euphemistic step away from ‘adult entertainment’). By keeping the Warhammer world we could have had our cake and eaten it, with both flavours of wargame existing to compliment each other, and a changed but recognisable world remaining to appeal to old-timers and newcomers drawn in by Warhammer: Total War alike. Plus, regardless of how hard-nosed and businesslike Games Workshop may be, no-one wants to launch their new golden (armoured) boys into the teeth of a hurricane of grousing.

Skaven

I’ve been so excited by all things Warhammer lately I painted my first Skaven in years.

In 40k the End Times have already happened. Of course there remains an abiding sense of impending, galaxy-wide apocalypse which characterises the setting (and plenty of doomsaying that threatens an End Times style destruction ahead) but the really big showdown happened ten millennia ago in the Horus Heresy. That is the point when the Imperium stopped being an expanding nation and turned into a bastion, when mankind stopped being a defining force in the galaxy and entered an age of inevitable decline that has defined it ever since. The Heresy has also spawned a hugely successful spin off game and series of books, which exists in partnership with 40k. I honestly expected something similar would happen with Warhammer, with Age of Sigmar becoming the ‘modern’ version and the Old World the Heresy-era equivalent.

Even after a year the background to Age of Sigmar still seems too strained and too abstract to be compelling, even when it manages to escape the marketing men’s hyperbole. Not that this should suggest that good stories can’t be pulled from the material – Godless by David Guymer is a cheap and highly entertaining way of disproving that – but the realms remain too big, the wars too infinite and everlasting, and the human perspective too distant to conjure the sense of hope that the setting aspires to.

Gav Thorpe (of Black Library fame) recently noted that for a long time “the idea of being able to translate the appeal of Space Marines into the fantasy setting had been something of an ambition, if not a specific objective.” The Warhammer universe was crying out for something to make it unique amongst its Fantasy peers and the introduction of the Stormcasts would have done that in spades –few things being so instantly recognisable as part of the Games Workshop brand as Space Marines. In principle then I have no issue with the Stormcasts, although once again I find the manner in which they were introduced rather contrived, with too much shown openly and too little mystery to fuel the imagination.

Skaven Advance

Gnawing at the roots of the world: my little rat army so far.

So people were upset by the destruction of the Old World. The vehemence of customer dissatisfaction seems to have caught Games Workshop off guard. People were – and still are – angry that the world they had grown to love had been so ruthlessly put to the sword. In some ways it all smacks of unbelievable levels of entitlement. Why should I kick up a fuss about changes being made to the story of a fantasy world when around the world a very real End Times are in progress? When real wars and famines slaughter millions what does the fate of a fictitious elf or two matter? When the jungles of Indonesia burn who cares that the jungles of Lustria do likewise? Surely we would be better served diverting our rage away from Games Workshop and pointing it at the governments and corporations around the globe who continue to put personal profits over the wellbeing of the environment? Or are we so divorced from reality that we would prefer to bury our heads in fantasy lands than face the sea of hungry faces at our doorstep?

Yet that misses the point. In fact it’s as lazy as criticising Tolkien’s writing simply because one is a devout socialist. It buys into a brutal work ethic that assigns value based purely on effort, where achieving a goal is less important than demonstrating that one worked hard to do it. Escapism is demeaned, as if only the lazy do not labour constantly. Let’s put the sackcloth and ashes aside for a moment before we find ourselves accepting the accusation that every fantasy fan is already familiar with – that we should have grown out of it by now. Rest and escapism is not a sin, and real life is hard enough without seeing the world we love blown to smithereens just because the current employees of the company that created it are bored of maintaining it.

It is precisely because the world is so often grim and dark that we need a little light, a little hope. I might prefer a Joe Abercrombie anti-hero struggling in the mud to a jolly rural farmboy who turns out to be a prince (or the son of a Jedi) but I’d be sounding damn stupid if I claimed that Lord of the Rings would have been better if Sauron had triumphed and the book had ended with a orc’s jackboot stamping on a hobbit’s face forever.

Grimgor Ironhide 1

Grimgor Ironhide: Gone from Games Workshop but still stamping ‘umies in Total War

People have been telling each other stories for as long as we’ve existed as a species. Those myths have often become the cornerstone of whole cultures, only to wither or evolve into new forms as those cultures were swept aside by history. The cultures may have vanished overnight but their stories did not. Imagine the horror of a tribal group who were told by their elders “we’ve thought about it and decided that all the gods and ancestors are dead now”. Suddenly those super-fans burning their armies on YouTube don’t seem so crazy after all. Fans of the Horus Heresy will know how Lorgar, the Emperor’s own super-fan, reacted when slighted by the subject of his devotion.

A question I’ve seen posed a lot in the last year is: “Games Workshop killed Warhammer, how can we ever trust them again?” I would ask why we were trusting them in the first place, and why that trust has now been violated. This isn’t about jobs or the environment, not even about overzealous legal teams and sky high prices. This is about the fans outsourcing the source of their enjoyment to another, allowing a commercial entity to take custody of their imaginations and then getting upset when it was demolished in order to balance the books.

The fact is that we humans are social creatures. Our memories and experiences are intrinsically linked to those of the group. I may revel in what I perceive to be my independence but, at an unconscious level, it matters to me that so many of my peers believe the Warhammer world I knew is dead.

And yet, in spite of what I joked in the first blog I wrote about this, Warhammer has never been destroyed, your army books and models have remained safe and sound, the rules and background did not crumble into dust on the 4th of July 2015 and no-one from Games Workshop has forced you at gunpoint to purchase Space Marines. Some might even suggest that, through Warhammer: Total War the Old World is now more real than ever before, although I would argue that something that’s been imagined over years will always be more real to the imaginer than something that’s merely shown. Nonetheless it’s harder to swallow the idea that iconic locations like Hel Fenn and Blackfire Pass have been consumed by a tidal wave of daemons when you can deploy your armies and march around it in a manner far more vivid than anything that was possible before.

Chaos Warrior

Some Warhammer armies are larger than others, as this group shot of my Warriors of Chaos serves to demonstrate…

The question then; does Warhammer: Total War replace Warhammer? And the answer; of course not, how could it? There’s no craftsmanship here that leads to the creation of a collection of models, none of the satisfaction of seeing an army growing through honest effort, none of the relaxation that hours of painting brings. What it does do is remind us that Warhammer is only dead if we want it to be. Just because a company decides to stop producing a range of books and re-labels a few models doesn’t mean you have to stop imagining. It’s not up to the developers at Total War to keep Warhammer alive. It’s up to you.

Artwork by Janice Duke. Click on them (I implore you!) to see the impressive full scale images.

Grimgor Ironhide and the Empire Captain by my mate Sam, check out more of his Warhammer models here.

Advertisements

17 responses to “Rising From The Ruins: The Rebirth of Warhammer

  • Alex

    Very thoughtful – and thought provoking! I’m actually growing more inclined to try AoS myself, (whereas the massive scale of WHFB always put me off…). interesting times!!!

    • Thomas

      Same here. The massed rank and file formations of Fantasy was never my thing. Nor did the Old World do it for me. It was pretty meh.

      Now the Age of Sigmar seems mighty fun, smaller armies, cool heroes and a looser game mechanism. I’ve bought, built and painted more models for Age of Sigmar than I ever did for Fantasy.

      And I really like how the game is in a constant flux and change. There is something new going on and I actually want get onboard and be a part of it.

      • Alex

        I hear you mate, and its a smart move allowing the interchange between the new Silver Tower game and AoS… I wonder if they’ll do an AoS scroll for the new Blood-bowl teams! That would be fun 🙂

      • Thomas

        In the Silver Tower app you can add (to a low cost) pretty much any plastic hero they’ve released to your heroes in the game. That’s an excellent move really. But Blood Bowl in regual AoS … naw, can’t see that really.

      • Alex

        lol – I’m sure BB will be set in some AoS realm or other – I can’t imagine it’ll be in the old world… the models I’ve seen for the orcs are certainly AoS-centric – SigMarine blockers anyone? 😀

      • Thomas

        It will be set in the realm of Fantasy Football.

      • Wudugast

        Perhaps that’s what happened to the Old World? It’s not being mined for Sigmarite it’s been built on and repurposed; Sigmar’s Stadium!

        As for AoS rules for the Blood Bowl teams, on reflection I don’t think I’d mind. It’s not really how I envision the realms but they are a big enough place and the human cultures there so unknown that there’s room for Blood Bowl to be being played somewhere currently out of sight. It wouldn’t spoil anything for me, whereas I think it would have bothered me a little bit if we were still in the Old World. I wonder if that’s because I was more attached to the Old World and had more rigid ideas of how it should be, or because I had been infected by the seriousness of the community at that time (AoS has undoubtedly scared off some of the more po-faced)?

  • beastofmanyshapes

    So many….. ideas, thoughts…..can’t process……socialism and wargaming for the win!!!

    Most of us are hardwired to only act upon issues that are happening 2 feet from our face. We can blame evolution for this trait. Then thank it for keeping us alive during humanities early days. Climate change is our end times and sociopathic, capitalists will deliver us and we will still be watching reality TV or getting overly upset about games in a dystopian future just before we are extinquished.

    Anyway wargaming……I completely agree. We need to take responsability for our own gaming and weave our the tales. Our only limit is our imagination.

    • Wudugast

      Sounds like you were feeling the same way reading it as I was writing it! Every new article I read whilst researching it sparked a new idea, more things to look up, more things to read, more rabbit holes to disappear down. In the end I had to rein it in otherwise it would be longer than a novel.

      I’m not sure it’s true, and it’s not intended to imply superiority, but it was put to me the other day that by engaging with fantasy fiction we stretch and exercise the imagination, making it stronger. We become more capable of considering theoretical concepts without needing to experience it ourselves (i.e. if one can put oneself in the shoes of a hobbit then one can put one’s self in the shoes of a refugee, or a tribal person seeing their lands destroyed for a mine, or a corporate boss who knows that if he can’t get his striking workforce to accept lower pay and conditions the whole business will collapse, etc). Furthermore we also become used to the idea that something that appears to be real might actually be a fiction (i.e. when I was reading Lord of the Rings hobbits seemed real, even though I know they aren’t*, so even though this newspaper article sounds real it might not be and I shouldn’t take it on faith). Personally I think as theories go it’s a little naive (I’ve met fantasy fans who were right bigots!) and even if there is anything to it the reality is probably much more complex. However it’s an interesting chain of thought all the same.

      *sorry if anyone wasn’t prepared for that revelation, I wish they were real too. I’d join them.

      • beastofmanyshapes

        I agree mostly, just by the nature of our hobby we tend to flex the brain more so than some. MAYBE this makes us more empothetic, open to employ maths for fun and learn historical facts. Its obviously not a rule as such but makes sense to me when I think of the people i know. Objective thinking is key, be a skeptic. Many many more rabbit holes. Anyway good write up!

  • krautscientist

    I can only agree with the other guys: A very well-considered and also very witty (An orcish jackboot stamping on a hobbit’s face forever — now that is just clever!) piece! Excellent stuff! A couple of thoughts, if I may:

    1. I agree that Total War Warhammer doesn’t replace the actual miniature game, but I think releasing such a game would have been pretty dangerous while the tabletop game was still being supported: I think the sheer scale of WHFB armies was something that scared many people off by the end, as having an army with less than a hundred models seemed almost impossible. I know it scared me off ever getting back into the game, because I always remembered the days when my chaos army with 50 models tops was a massive force of several thousand points. Therefore, giving people the option to have the experience of playing with huge armies in a beautifully rendered digital environment could well have been a problem — believe it or not, but there seems to be a sizeable amount of hobbyists for whom the whole craftsmanship is merely a means to an end, and not an actual end in itself. The same is true for many people just getting into the hobby: Everyone wants a brilliant-looking army, but not nearly everyone is prepared to put in the amount of time, work and, well, money — and why should they, really, when a far more comfortable way exists for staging huge battles in this world? That’s why I think that, in some ways, they were only really free to release that game now, where it can no longer hurt their miniature sales quite as badly 😉

    2. Silver Tower seems a very interesting move in that it feels distinctly Hero Quest-ly to, and it almost seems to bridge the gap between the Old World and the new realms — I mean, who really gives a damn where that silver tower is actually situated, right? Plus the characters are still close enough to WHFB lore that the game should please the retro crowd as well, even if it’s mainly from an aesthetic standpoint. In fact, I cannot help wondering if a game like this wouldn’t have been a far better way of introducing the new setting: A tightly focused experience with a colourful cast of heroes and villains – again, just like HeroQuest, really – to draw people in and get them hooked on the look and feel of the world. Allowing the plastic clamshell characters to be used as additional characters and heroes was a brilliant idea — why not start with that and build from there, instead of creating a massive world in very broad strokes that nobody really cares about — yet.

    3. Last but not least, I couldn’t agree more with your assessment about WHFB still being available for those who want to play it: In a way, having the game set free like that can be a very positive thing, as evidenced by Necromunda, Inquisitor or by groups like the whole Oldhammer crowd — seriously, who’s to ever stop us from playing games using the exact version of rules we are comfortable with and setting it in the Old World? Show a bit of initiative, people!

    Anyway, thanks again for the excellent read!

    • Wudugast

      Cheers mate! 🙂 Excellent and thought provoking comment, allow me work my way through it.

      1. I tend to agree. Even though I love painting the size of the two armies I showed above shows exactly how far I got. It’s not just the size of the armies, it’s the weeks of work that would go into creating a battlefield that looked as good as the kind of thing that appears on a computer screen at the touch of a button. When you get up to the level of organising a campaign against multiple opponents the effort and investment is huge. I’m not saying it wouldn’t be a lot of fun but when you compare it to clicking a couple of buttons and off you go it doesn’t really add up.
      As I recall the idea behind Apocalypse was to allow people whose collections had outgrown standard games of 40k to play with them all at once. I once read that the idea behind the first edition of WHFB was the same, people who’s collection of miniatures for roleplaying games had grown particularly large could now play them all together in larger battles. The later editions of WHFB seemed to forget this, it was all about the huge armies and in many ways I think that was its downfall. A sliding scale would have done a lot for it, with a sympathetic merging of the AoS and WHFB rulesets and backgrounds allowing players to find a level that suited them, or scale from one to the other as they felt like it.

      2. In my personal ‘head canon’ I often imagine that the Silver Tower allows travel from the Old World to the Realms. This is Tzeentch we’re dealing with after all! 😉
      Anyway, I completely agree that a small detailed setting, with engaging events and characters would have drawn me in a lot more than the grand, mythic epic of AoS. Then the world could build up from there. Personally I’ve got nothing against the realms, I’m just not engaged by them – yet.

      3. The way that Inq28, Necromunda etc have been “taken back” by the fans is, for me, the most inspiring thing that’s happened to miniatures’ games, possibly ever. The sheer degree of creativity and free thought that has surrounded it has been a joy to watch. It would be wonderful to see more of that happening with WHFB, more passion and creativity and less grousing. It may be however that WHFB was too big and too well established to go feral easily but I remain optimistic!

  • The Empire Strikes Again | Convert or Die

    […] I even painted up a couple of heroes for the Empire collection I almost started and, given that I’ve got Warhammer on the brain at the moment, now seemed like a very good time to show them off.First of all there’s this captain, just […]

  • The Art of Janice Duke | Convert or Die

    […] may have noticed that my recent (rather wordy!) article on Warhammer: Total War and the recent changes that have occurred to the Warhammer universe, featured several pieces of art […]

  • The Responsible One

    The Total War people at WarhammerFest said that the ambition was to make an army for anything that had an army book in 8th “plus one other”, which I would guess to be Chaos Dwarves.

    • Wudugast

      Fishmen 😉
      All joking apart that is very interesting news. For one thing it allays my fears about some of the smaller races (beastmen, tomb kings). As for the ‘one other’ the only candidates I can think of beyond Chaos Dwarves would Dogs of War (would make good DLC but would hardly work as a faction in their own right) or united chaos combining all chaotic factions (pretty much pointless when I guarantee a modder will release something within about 10 seconds of additional chaos races becoming available). Fingers tightly crossed your right and Chaos Dwarves it is! That would make me an extremely happy chap! 🙂

  • 2016 – For Anyone Who Missed It | Convert or Die

    […] seen the return of the Old World of Warhammer (the World That Was – Age of Sigmar kids) through Total War: Warhammer (a game to which, I have to confess, I’ve developed a considerable addiction and which has […]

Speak, damn you!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: